Insurance agency owner at his desk looking worried at his computer, with papers spread across the desk
Insurance agency owner at his desk looking worried at his computer, with papers spread across the desk
Insurance agency owner at his desk looking worried at his computer, with papers spread across the desk

Stop wondering if you'll make payroll this month.

Fractional CFO services for insurance agency owners. Forward-looking strategy and driver-based forecasting, delivered by people who truly understand finance. Not accounting wrapped in a finance label.

You built a real business. Finance never caught up. 

You built a real business. Finance never caught up. 

You built a real business. Finance never caught up. 

The Problem

Every unexpected expense or smaller-than-usual commission check feels like a setback.

Your bonus check ends up paying down last year’s debt, or finally becomes the owner income you should have been taking all along.

You make six-figure decisions on gut feel, not a real forecast.

When a peer asks how the agency is doing, you say “great” by default, not by conviction.

If any of this feels familiar, you’re not alone. This isn’t a personal failing. It’s getting experienced financial guidance so you can focus on what you do best. Growing your agency.

Phil Rice, founder of instantCFO

You need a finance partner, not another vendor.

I know what it’s like to run an agency and still not feel in control of the numbers. I own one. I started instantCFO because I saw the gap firsthand. Agency owners at your stage deserve the kind of financial rigor that Fortune 500 executives get from their FP&A teams. Not more bookkeeping. Not more services layered onto what you already have. Real finance. That combination, an active agency operator with enterprise-scale finance experience, is exactly the perspective instantCFO brings to your business.

Phil Rice

Founder, instantCFO

20+ years leading corporate finance teams at Expedia and American Airlines

BBA, University of Texas at Arlington (UTA) · MBA, Southern Methodist University (SMU)

Owns and manages an active insurance agency

Your first 60 days: the Foundation. 

Your first 60 days: the Foundation. 

Your first 60 days: the Foundation. 

Every engagement starts with the Foundation, your first 60 days. We run your agency’s numbers through the same five tests every time, show you exactly where the money is going and what you can sustainably pay yourself, and hand you a prioritized roadmap. Then Cornerstone puts the roadmap to work for the rest of the year.

1

Intake (Days 1–15)

We start with a one-hour Business Overview call to learn your agency, your numbers, and what's keeping you up at night. Then we connect to your QuickBooks or Xero and pull your commission and revenue detail.

Business Overview call

Connect QuickBooks or Xero, gather commission and revenue data

1

Intake (Days 1–15)

We start with a one-hour Business Overview call to learn your agency, your numbers, and what's keeping you up at night. Then we connect to your QuickBooks or Xero and pull your commission and revenue detail.

Business Overview call

Connect QuickBooks or Xero, gather commission and revenue data

1

Intake (Days 1–15)

We start with a one-hour Business Overview call to learn your agency, your numbers, and what's keeping you up at night. Then we connect to your QuickBooks or Xero and pull your commission and revenue detail.

Business Overview call

Connect QuickBooks or Xero, gather commission and revenue data

2

Diagnosis (Days 16–40)

Your numbers run through a fixed five-category panel. Every client gets the same tests, so nothing gets missed: revenue composition, expense structure, expense-to-revenue ratios against benchmark, cash flow timing and owner pay, and financial organization.

Five-category financial diagnostic

Expense-to-revenue benchmarking

2

Diagnosis (Days 16–40)

Your numbers run through a fixed five-category panel. Every client gets the same tests, so nothing gets missed: revenue composition, expense structure, expense-to-revenue ratios against benchmark, cash flow timing and owner pay, and financial organization.

Five-category financial diagnostic

Expense-to-revenue benchmarking

2

Diagnosis (Days 16–40)

Your numbers run through a fixed five-category panel. Every client gets the same tests, so nothing gets missed: revenue composition, expense structure, expense-to-revenue ratios against benchmark, cash flow timing and owner pay, and financial organization.

Five-category financial diagnostic

Expense-to-revenue benchmarking

3

Findings (Days 41–60)

We walk through your Financial Health Report together on a live call, with a prioritized roadmap: what needs work, in what order, and why. From there, Cornerstone puts the roadmap to work for the rest of the year.

Financial Health Report

Prioritized roadmap to profitability

3

Findings (Days 41–60)

We walk through your Financial Health Report together on a live call, with a prioritized roadmap: what needs work, in what order, and why. From there, Cornerstone puts the roadmap to work for the rest of the year.

Financial Health Report

Prioritized roadmap to profitability

3

Findings (Days 41–60)

We walk through your Financial Health Report together on a live call, with a prioritized roadmap: what needs work, in what order, and why. From there, Cornerstone puts the roadmap to work for the rest of the year.

Financial Health Report

Prioritized roadmap to profitability

No hourly clock. No open-ended scope. Works with QuickBooks or Xero.

If nothing changes:

The cost of another year of guessing.

The cash anxiety doesn’t go away. Every smaller-than-usual commission check feels like a setback. The mental cost adds up in ways nobody talks about.

Big decisions keep getting made on gut feel. Hiring, marketing, expansion, all sized against instinct instead of a forecast.

Bonus targets keep moving. You build your agency for this year’s targets, and then next year’s targets change the dynamic. You’re always retrofitting.

Real profit stays out of reach. You don’t know where the leaks are, so the leaks keep leaking. Next year looks like this year, or worse.

Twelve months in, here’s what changes:

The other side of a year of real finance.

You lead your agency on a plan, not on worry. The financial questions running in the back of your mind quiet down. You already know. You get your bandwidth back for the parts of the business you actually enjoy.

You make decisions from your own numbers. Every hire, every marketing decision, every big purchase gets sized against a real forward view of your agency’s cash and profit. No more guessing.

Bonus season becomes a time to celebrate the wins, not catch up on last year’s debts. You know what it’s actually costing to hit the targets, which levers move the number, and how to protect margin along the way.

Your agency runs on a rhythm. Monthly financial review, quarterly planning, annual budget. The same operating cadence that a $100M business unit runs on, sized to your agency. You show up prepared, not scrambling.

This is what a year of real finance looks like.

Real finance is not accounting in a finance role.

Most agency owners hire an accountant and assume that covers the finance side of the business too. It’s an honest mistake. The two disciplines look similar from the outside. They both involve numbers, spreadsheets, and monthly deliverables. They are not the same thing.

Accounting looks backward.

It categorizes what has happened, produces reliable historical records, and files your taxes accurately. A good accountant is a valuable team member. Every serious business needs one.

Accounting looks backward.

It categorizes what has happened, produces reliable historical records, and files your taxes accurately. A good accountant is a valuable team member. Every serious business needs one.

Finance looks forward.

It builds forecasts, models decisions, evaluates trade-offs, and drives strategy. It is comfortable with uncertainty. It requires a fundamentally different way of thinking.

Finance looks forward.

It builds forecasts, models decisions, evaluates trade-offs, and drives strategy. It is comfortable with uncertainty. It requires a fundamentally different way of thinking.

Think of it like a screwdriver and a hammer. Both are essential tools. Both belong in the toolbox. But you wouldn’t use a screwdriver to drive a nail, no matter how well-made the screwdriver is.

When you ask your accountant to build a driver-based forecast, evaluate a new producer hire, or model your cash position across the next quarter, you’re asking a screwdriver to drive a nail. It might get done. But will it be done well?

instantCFO is the finance side of that toolbox. Sized for your agency, focused on where you’re going, and built to work with your accountant.